2015 NFL Rookie of the Year Odds

2015 NFL Rookie of the Year Odds

The NFL Draft concluded on Saturday, May 2nd and on Tuesday (5/26) morning Bovada became the first major offshore sportsbook to post odds for the 2015 NFL Rookie of the Year. Although Jameis Winston and Marcus Mariota were the first two selections, neither quarterback opened as the favorite — that honor belongs to Chargers 1st round selection Melvin Gordon.

Last season at Wisconsin, the 6’1 back nearly broke the single-season rushing record with 2,587 yards and 29 touchdowns. That includes a record-breaking 408 rushing yards against Nebraska — a mark which lasted for only one week. With Ryan Mathews gone, Gordon should receive the lion’s share of the workload for San Diego which helps explain why the 15th overall pick would have the shortest odds.

The table below compares the early NFL Rookie of the Year odds at Bovada and BetOnline with the most recent update from 5Dimes. This data will be updated as the season approaches and, as always, we encourage bettors to shop for the best line.

PlayerTeamBovada (10/8)5Dimes (8/14)Bovada (5/26)BetOnline (5/16)Bovada (5/6)Bovada (5/5)
Marcus MariotaTennessee Titans+250+1000+1000+1000+900+700
Amari CooperOakland Raiders+300+650+750+700+750+750
Todd GurleySt. Louis Rams+300+900+1200+850+800+800
Melvin GordonSan Diego Chargers+750+700+750+600+650+650
TJ YeldonJacksonville Jaguars+1200+2000+1000+1200+1200+1200
Tyler LockettSeattle Seahawks+1200+2500+2000+2500+1800+2500
Karlos WilliamsBuffalo Bills+1200N/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
Jameis WinstonTampa Bay Buccaneers+1400+550+400+600+700+700
Duke JohnsonCleveland Browns+1500+4000+2800+3300+2500+2500
Ameer AbdullahDetroit Lions+2000+2500+2500+2000+2500+2500
David JohnsonArizona Cardinals+2000+3300+3300N/A+2500N/A
Matt JonesWashington Redskins+2000+5000N/AN/AN/AN/A
Kevin WhiteChicago BearsN/A+1200+1200+800+1000+1000
Nelson AgholorPhiladelphia EaglesN/A+1400+1000+1200+1400+1400
Breshad PerrimanBaltimore RavensN/A+2500+1000+1800+2500+2200
Tevin ColemanAtlanta FalconsN/A+2500+2500+1800N/AN/A
DeVante ParkerMiami DolphinsN/A+2500+2500+1500+1600+1600
Phillip DorsettIndianapolis ColtsN/A+2500+3300+1600+1600+1400
Devin SmithNew York JetsN/A+2500+3300+2200+2200+2200
Dorial Green-BeckhamTennessee TitansN/A+2800+2500+1800+2500+1800
Maxx WilliamsBaltimore RavensN/A+3300+2800N/A+1600+1400
Jaelen StrongHouston TexansN/A+3300+3300+2200+2500+2500
Chris ConleyKansas City ChiefsN/A+3300+2500+3300+2500+2500
Devin FunchessCarolina PanthersN/A+4000+3300+2000+2500+2200
Tyler KroftCincinnati BengalsN/A+5000N/AN/AN/AN/A
Sammie CoatesPittsburgh SteelersN/A+5000N/AN/AN/AN/A
Bryce PettyNew York JetsN/A+6500N/AN/AN/AN/A
Andrus PeatNew Orleans SaintsN/A+6500N/AN/AN/AN/A
Clive WalfordOakland RaidersN/A+6600N/AN/AN/AN/A
Garrett GraysonNew Orleans SaintsN/A+6600N/AN/AN/AN/A
Jay AjayiMiami DolphinsN/A+6600N/AN/AN/AN/A
Ereck FlowersNew York GiantsN/A+7000N/AN/AN/AN/A
Lael CollinsDallas CowboysN/A+10000N/AN/AN/AN/A
Ty MontgomeryGreen Bay PackersN/A+10000N/AN/AN/AN/A
Jeremy LangfordChicago BearsN/A+10000N/AN/AN/AN/A
Brandon ScherffWashington RedskinsN/A+12500N/AN/AN/AN/A
Cameron Artis-PayneCarolina PanthersN/A+12500N/AN/AN/AN/A
Justin HardyAtlanta FalconsN/A+12500N/AN/AN/AN/A
Sean MannionSt. Louis RamsN/A+12500N/AN/AN/AN/A
TJ ClemmingsMinnesota VikingsN/A+12500N/AN/AN/AN/A
DJ HumphriesArizona CardinalsN/A+15000N/AN/AN/AN/A
Jamison CrowderWashington RedskinsN/A+15000N/AN/AN/AN/A

Although Melvin Gordon opened as the favorite, Jameis Winston saw his odds skyrocket, moving from +700 to +400 within three weeks of this prop being released. In that same time Marcus Mariota dropped from +700 to +1000 and Todd Gurley dropped from +800 to +1200.

One of the largest risers is Ravens first round draft pick Breshad Perriman. The 6’2″ receiver didn’t post exceptional stats last season at Central Florida (50 receptions for 1,044 yards and 9 touchdowns), but his elite speed and big-play ability make him an interesting option for Joe Flacco — especially as the team attempts to replace Torrey Smith.

Some of the largest discrepancies between Bovada and BetOnline include: Kevin White (+1200 vs. +800), Breshad Perriman (+1000 vs. +1800), Dorial Green-Beckham (+2500 vs. +1800), Chris Conley (+2500 vs. +3300) and Phillip Dorsett (+3300 vs. +1600). It’s also interesting to see that bettors aren’t buying the hype on Marcus Mariota as his Rookie of the Year odds continue to slip.

It was also interesting to see that 5Dimes player pool was significantly larger than those at Bovada or BetOnline and included a number of late round selections and offensive linemen. This is particularly interesting since five of the last six Rookie of the Year winners have been first round picks, and no offensive lineman has ever won the award.

The table below displays the preseason Offensive Rookie of the Year odds for the past six seasons. (via SportsOddsHistory)

YearPlayer (Pos)TeamRound (Pick)Odds
2009Pervy Harvin (WR)Minnesota Vikings1 (22)+1200
2010Sam Bradford (QB)St. Louis Rams1 (1)+500
2011Cam Newton (QB)Carolina Panthers1 (1)+400
2012Robert Griffin III (QB)Washington Redskins1 (2)+400
2013Eddie Lacy (RB)Green Bay Packers2 (61)+800
2014Odell Beckham Jr. (WR)New York Giants1 (12)+2500

Along with these Rookie of the Year odds, Bovada also posted a number of prop bets for this incoming class. Note that all quarterbacks must start Week 1, running backs must receive at least 1 carry in Week 1, and wide receivers must play in Week 1 for action.

– Jameis Winston (1st overall pick by Tampa Bay)

O/U 3,750 passing yards, 19.5 TD passes, 17.5 interceptions

– Marcus Mariota (2nd overall pick by Tennessee)

O/U 3,400 passing yards, 425.5 rushing yards, 18.5 TD passes

– Amari Cooper (4th overall pick by Oakland)

O/U 900.5 receiving yards, 5.5 TD receptions.

– Kevin White (7th overall by Chicago)

O/U 800.5 receiving yards, 6 TD receptions

– Todd Gurley (10th overall pick by St. Louis)

O/U 750.5 rushing yards, 5 rushing TD

– DeVante Parker (14th overall pick by Miami)

O/U 750.5 receiving yards, 5 TD receptions

– Melvin Gordon (15th overall pick by St. Louis)

O/U 900.5 rushing yards, 6 rushing TD

– Nelson Agholor (20th overall pick by Philadelphia)

O/U 700.5 receiving yards, 4.5 TD receptions

– Vic Beasley (8th overall pick by Atlanta)

O/U 8 sacks | +1,000 to win Defensive ROY


Bettors should know that Derek Carr led all rookie quarterbacks with 3,163 passing yards, Jeremy Hill led all rookie running backs with 1,144 rushing yards, Odell Beckham led all rookie receivers with 1,305 receiving yards and Aaron Donald led all rookies with 9 sacks.

Although Andrew Luck did amass over 4,300 passing yards during his rookie season, he was viewed as a once-in-a-generation player. When you consider that Russell Wilson (3,475), Andy Dalton (3,398), Colin Kaepernick (3,369) and Cam Newton (3,127) all passed for under 3,500 yards last season, it would seem that Bovada is expecting an influx on public money on the over for both Winston and Mariota.

Based on recent history, it would seem as though the under for both Winston (3,700 yards) and Mariota (3,400 yards) seem to be offering value.


10/8/15 Update

After four weeks of action, Bovada became the first prominent offshore sportsbook to update their Rookie of the Year odds. Marcus Mariota, who has passed for 833 yards with 8 touchdowns and 2 interceptions in three games, moved from +1000 to +250 at Bovada based on the strength of his early season performance.

Jameis Winston, who was selected with the first overall pick, has struggled in the early going and has slipped from +550 to +1400. Although he was the preseason favorite, Winston now has just the eighth best odds.

Easily the biggest riser was Buffalo Bills running back Karlos Williams. A fifth round pick out of Florida State, no sportsbook posted Rookie of the Year odds on Williams prior to the start of the season. However, the 6’1″ 230-pounder has racked up 226 rushing yards, 46 receiving yards and 4 total touchdowns. He’s still expected to back-up LeSean McCoy, but McCoy has struggled with injuries this season.

Have any questions for the staff at Sports Insights? Utilize our live chat to speak with a customer service representative or e-mail us at help@sportsinsights.com.

David Solar is the Content Manager for Sports Insights and can be reached directly at David@sportsinsights.com.

Join us live Sundays at noon ET

We’re now holding our members-only live Sports Betting Hangouts Sunday mornings to prepare you for a full day of NFL games. Members, simply log into your account Sunday morning to access the hangout.

Not a member? Start a trial today to join our Sports Betting Hangouts held six days a week, plus all the other Sportsbook Insider Pro benefits.

Get Started Now


David Solar

David was the Content Manager at Sports Insights. He has since moved on to greener pastures.

No Comments
Post a Comment

Send this to friend